Here are a few things I don't understand about the health care reform debate. In particular, things I don't understand the media keeps letting the Republicans repeat ad nauseum:
I just don't understand how Republicans can keep making arguments that a government plan, or a public option, will lead to some new and terrifying "rationing" of care. "Oh, no your doctor will recommend something and some government bureaucrat will deny it!" We ALREADY HAVE rationing of care. Ask any doctor in this country - private insurance companies ration care by denying treatment all the time. And if you don't have insurance, then your care is rationed simply by your ability to pay. God forbid we ration care differently than we do now - say, by its effectiveness - because let's be honest, medical care is rationed now and always will be. Why? Because medical care, like any other resource, is not infinite or free.
Ditto for the scaaaaary talk about not being able to go to any doctor you want. Have these Republicans ever heard the phrase "out-of-network"? I'd say most Americans are already used to having to choose their doctors from a list provided by their private insurance companies. (And those who don't have insurance - if they can even afford to go to anything but the ER - are lucky to find a doctor who will take them at all.) Please don't pretend that the Fatherland is going to start assigning every person, without recourse, a single doctor (god forbid we have that kind of continuity of care anyway).
Finally, Republicans, please stop talking about the government being forced to pay for abortion under health care reform. Much as I would personally like to see every insurance company mandated to provide abortion coverage - most already do - AND the public option cover abortion, it will not happen and we all know it. Yes, theoretically it is possible that you could give someone a subsidy for health insurance, which they would use to purchase a private plan, which would cover abortion, which they would then need and receive. You also already give people money via the welfare system which they could use to pay for abortion, and give them food stamps which they could use to buy food which would then free up money that they could use for an abortion. If you don't want people to get abortions, then you should not give anyone money ever in any way, because they could theoretically use it to pay for abortion, since - funny, this - abortion is legal.
So those are a few things I don't understand. If any Republican members of Congress who read my blog want to explain them to me, please feel free.
Doula, master's of public health graduate, new IBCLC, and feminist. I'm reflecting on my studies, reflecting on other people's studies, posting news, telling stories, and inviting discussion on reproductive health from birth control to birth to bra fitting.
Friday, July 31, 2009
Wednesday, July 29, 2009
Update your links
On my short list of blogs you should be reading (besides mine) is Jill's The Unnecesarean. She recently had a sad case of domain-stealing, so update your links from Unnecesarean.com to TheUnnecesarean.com (or add it now if you haven't yet).
Just recently she has had in-depth information and discussion on how refusing an unnecessary c-section led to loss of custody, the outcome of charges against a doctor for being abusive towards a woman in labor, and noted the new Cochrane Review stating that use of antibiotics for GBS in labor is not supported by evidence. See? You don't want to miss this! And I can't link to all of it (just a lot).
Just recently she has had in-depth information and discussion on how refusing an unnecessary c-section led to loss of custody, the outcome of charges against a doctor for being abusive towards a woman in labor, and noted the new Cochrane Review stating that use of antibiotics for GBS in labor is not supported by evidence. See? You don't want to miss this! And I can't link to all of it (just a lot).
Tuesday, July 28, 2009
Saving women's lives in Afghanistan
Afghanistan has one of the highest maternal mortality ratios in the world (only Sierra Leone's is worse). In a culture where women grow up without proper nutrition, are married off and begin childbearing too young, are denied education and basic human rights - things start bad and then just get worse.
Pashtoon Azfar is working to change that; she's the president of the Afghan Midwives Association and she's been pushing education in not only technical skills but interpersonal skills. This is crucial as women who aren't accustomed to using medical personnel for births aren't going to trust someone who's, well, not nice.
“Does she greet the mother properly?” she asked. “Offer her a chair? A drink of water? Introduce herself? Let the mother ask questions? They are trained. They have to do it.”
Such simple steps that so many maternity care providers could use! It's not just about technical skills - it's also about trust. Read more here.
"These midwives, they are champions. Oh, I love them. They are my heart."
Pashtoon Azfar is working to change that; she's the president of the Afghan Midwives Association and she's been pushing education in not only technical skills but interpersonal skills. This is crucial as women who aren't accustomed to using medical personnel for births aren't going to trust someone who's, well, not nice.
“Does she greet the mother properly?” she asked. “Offer her a chair? A drink of water? Introduce herself? Let the mother ask questions? They are trained. They have to do it.”
Such simple steps that so many maternity care providers could use! It's not just about technical skills - it's also about trust. Read more here.
"These midwives, they are champions. Oh, I love them. They are my heart."
You can VBAC in a car, you can VBAC near or far
OK, sorry about the title. But anyway: Mother VBACs in speeding car.
Not just any VBAC - a VBAC after 3 c-sections (I'm assuming - they say their older three daughters were also born via c-section, although if some - or even all - were multiples that would reduce the total number).
After the "breech baby born in speeding ambulance" this story is suggesting to me if you want a vaginal birth, the best place to get it might be in a speeding vehicle?
Not just any VBAC - a VBAC after 3 c-sections (I'm assuming - they say their older three daughters were also born via c-section, although if some - or even all - were multiples that would reduce the total number).
After the "breech baby born in speeding ambulance" this story is suggesting to me if you want a vaginal birth, the best place to get it might be in a speeding vehicle?
Monday, July 27, 2009
IKEA misses the memo - breastfeeding in public is legal
A mother at the Ikea in Red Hook, Brooklyn was asked to move to the bathroom to finish breastfeeding her daughter. The comments on the blog post are pretty standard, including a former breastfeeding mom who puts down this woman's "poor planning" in not having pumped a bottle of milk in advance. Whoops! The mother who was asked to move must have forgotten that babies are born to be breastfed only in private. Perhaps the commenter was also forgetful, as she forgot - as the Ikea security guards seem to have - that women have a right to breastfeed in New York State anywhere they are legally allowed to be. As several more astute commenters pointed out, the security guards had no more right to escort her to the bathroom for openly breastfeeding than they did to escort someone to the bathroom for being say, openly black.
Here's the bottom line for me, and what a lot of the commenters don't seem to get: you don't have to like certain things. You don't have to like breastfeeding in public, or gay people holding hands, or someone wearing skimpy clothes. But these things are legal. If you choose, you can be a jerk about those things you don't like. The law doesn't and can't prohibit dirty looks or rude words; only common decency does. But companies and their employees are subject to the law, and by law cannot force a breastfeeding woman to move just because they don't like public breastfeeding. The end. What happened in Ikea shouldn't have happened and shouldn't happen again.
I find the whole thing particularly ironic since Ikea is Swedish and Sweden is an international model for its very high breastfeeding rates. I find it hard to imagine a mother in a Swedish Ikea being escorted to the bathroom for feeding her baby. They would have to escort something like 80% of them. I assume that's why their p.r. person gets it when she says: "This incident is being looked into as this totally goes against our culture and focus on family." Maybe the Swedes forgot that their American employees would need some extra training? (Interestingly, the thread where the original Ikea story was posted has another asked-to-stop-nursing-in-public story at a New York H&M, also a Swedish chain.)
(It's also not a great store location for this to happen in, given that scaring up a crowd of Brooklyn moms for a nurse-in would be as easy as walking around the playground.)
In any case, it sounds like both sides are responding actively to what happened, which is good. I'm curious to see what more (if any) news comes of this...
(Thanks to my friend and classmate Adriane for passing this along!)
Here's the bottom line for me, and what a lot of the commenters don't seem to get: you don't have to like certain things. You don't have to like breastfeeding in public, or gay people holding hands, or someone wearing skimpy clothes. But these things are legal. If you choose, you can be a jerk about those things you don't like. The law doesn't and can't prohibit dirty looks or rude words; only common decency does. But companies and their employees are subject to the law, and by law cannot force a breastfeeding woman to move just because they don't like public breastfeeding. The end. What happened in Ikea shouldn't have happened and shouldn't happen again.
I find the whole thing particularly ironic since Ikea is Swedish and Sweden is an international model for its very high breastfeeding rates. I find it hard to imagine a mother in a Swedish Ikea being escorted to the bathroom for feeding her baby. They would have to escort something like 80% of them. I assume that's why their p.r. person gets it when she says: "This incident is being looked into as this totally goes against our culture and focus on family." Maybe the Swedes forgot that their American employees would need some extra training? (Interestingly, the thread where the original Ikea story was posted has another asked-to-stop-nursing-in-public story at a New York H&M, also a Swedish chain.)
(It's also not a great store location for this to happen in, given that scaring up a crowd of Brooklyn moms for a nurse-in would be as easy as walking around the playground.)
In any case, it sounds like both sides are responding actively to what happened, which is good. I'm curious to see what more (if any) news comes of this...
(Thanks to my friend and classmate Adriane for passing this along!)
Saturday, July 25, 2009
"From Worst to First" - Getting hospitals to change their ways
There's an inspirational campaign going on in New Jersey called "From Worst to First". With New Jersey at a 39.4% cesarean rate, they are publicly naming and shaming hospitals with high cesarean (and episiotomy) rates. Once there are women out front of a hospital with brightly colored signs saying "Bad Maternity Care Harms Women", most hospital administrations seem eager to at least meet with them.
The Worst to First website is here - if you scroll down to "Status of New Jersey Hospitals Addressed by NJMCWTF2010" you can click on individual hospitals and see photos of each protest and a short report of what happened.
I learned about this campaign through e-mails via a doula listserv. The e-mail reports were longer and more detailed than the reports on the website, and I thought I'd share an excerpt of one here:
We met with the Administrative staff of Saint Clare's Hospital in Denville
on June 8th, 2009 for a meeting to discuss the first steps towards our "Worst to First" Campaign.
In attendance was the Administrative Director of Nursing, the Maternal Child
Education Coordinator, the Communications Manager, the Executive Vice President of the Hospital, the Patient Care Manager, the Maternal Child Heath Coordinator, the Vice President of Public Affairs, the Labor and Delivery Staff Nurse and Doula, Quality Manager of Maternity, and the Director of Clinical Quality. Stacey Gregg Action VP for NOW-NJ, Anne Mitchell Stacey Gregg's Summer College Intern/Activist, & Morris County NOW Secretary Doreen Manno.
For the first hour and a half of the meeting, Stacey and the administration went back and forth about the condition and quality of patient care and how it was reflected negatively in the statistics that we're trying to break with our campaign.
Unfortunately before this point, the hospital staff present was unwilling to admit their statistics. They were trying to question the validity of the state's statistics of the ten hospitals that already really have episiotomy rates below 5%.
It wasn't until Stacey made the analogy between the unnecessary cutting of woman during birth and how if a woman was a rape victim, you would not be discussing the reasons why a rapist does what they do. You would only be concerned with coming up with solutions and ways to protect her. She gave the examples of a rapist claiming any justifications "didn't have enough time, it takes to long the other way"," that's the way I was trained to do it", "the women want it or they ask for it", and "they don't mind it this way", the way a doctor might defend his high rate of episiotomies. She stated that she did not want to discuss how they got here it just had to stop, and she took one of the signs that we had bought with us into the room that stated "STOP Violence Against Women" and stated that Women are being harmed. ...
"There are ten hospitals with low episiotomy rates that are doing things differently; obviously they're not doing the same things that are going on around here." Stacey said. ... Discussion was held about how to get the doctors to best respond and change the way they practice. From there, we began to formulate an action plan to reduce episiotomy rates at Saint Clare's.
Wow.
On the doula listserv I get these e-mails through, doulas are saying "We need to do this in OUR state!" Is it too much to hope this goes nationwide? I'll head up my state's chapter!
The Worst to First website is here - if you scroll down to "Status of New Jersey Hospitals Addressed by NJMCWTF2010" you can click on individual hospitals and see photos of each protest and a short report of what happened.
I learned about this campaign through e-mails via a doula listserv. The e-mail reports were longer and more detailed than the reports on the website, and I thought I'd share an excerpt of one here:
We met with the Administrative staff of Saint Clare's Hospital in Denville
on June 8th, 2009 for a meeting to discuss the first steps towards our "Worst to First" Campaign.
In attendance was the Administrative Director of Nursing, the Maternal Child
Education Coordinator, the Communications Manager, the Executive Vice President of the Hospital, the Patient Care Manager, the Maternal Child Heath Coordinator, the Vice President of Public Affairs, the Labor and Delivery Staff Nurse and Doula, Quality Manager of Maternity, and the Director of Clinical Quality. Stacey Gregg Action VP for NOW-NJ, Anne Mitchell Stacey Gregg's Summer College Intern/Activist, & Morris County NOW Secretary Doreen Manno.
For the first hour and a half of the meeting, Stacey and the administration went back and forth about the condition and quality of patient care and how it was reflected negatively in the statistics that we're trying to break with our campaign.
Unfortunately before this point, the hospital staff present was unwilling to admit their statistics. They were trying to question the validity of the state's statistics of the ten hospitals that already really have episiotomy rates below 5%.
It wasn't until Stacey made the analogy between the unnecessary cutting of woman during birth and how if a woman was a rape victim, you would not be discussing the reasons why a rapist does what they do. You would only be concerned with coming up with solutions and ways to protect her. She gave the examples of a rapist claiming any justifications "didn't have enough time, it takes to long the other way"," that's the way I was trained to do it", "the women want it or they ask for it", and "they don't mind it this way", the way a doctor might defend his high rate of episiotomies. She stated that she did not want to discuss how they got here it just had to stop, and she took one of the signs that we had bought with us into the room that stated "STOP Violence Against Women" and stated that Women are being harmed. ...
"There are ten hospitals with low episiotomy rates that are doing things differently; obviously they're not doing the same things that are going on around here." Stacey said. ... Discussion was held about how to get the doctors to best respond and change the way they practice. From there, we began to formulate an action plan to reduce episiotomy rates at Saint Clare's.
Wow.
On the doula listserv I get these e-mails through, doulas are saying "We need to do this in OUR state!" Is it too much to hope this goes nationwide? I'll head up my state's chapter!
Thursday, July 23, 2009
Newflash: breech baby born vaginally
I like the breathless tone of this one - "Even though the baby was turned the wrong way" he somehow survived!
Breech baby born in the back of a racing ambulance.
Breech baby born in the back of a racing ambulance.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)